The Top 5 Questions Brands Are Asking Agencies in 2026

· Articles

The Top 5 Questions Brands Are Asking Agencies in 2026

Phil here, Director of Paid Social. I'm speaking to brands every week. Different stages, different spend levels, different problems. Some are trying to fix what's broken, others are trying to build on what's working.

After hundreds of these conversations, patterns emerge. The same questions keep coming up.

If you're brand-side, this might help you see over the fence; are other brands facing the same struggles? If you're agency-side, you're probably answering these questions yourself.

Here are the top 5 questions brands are asking us this year.

1. How many creative assets do we need to succeed?

The assumption is always: more assets = more success. 200 PNGs must be better than 100 PNGs, right?

Not even close.

Brands fixate on hitting a specific number of assets, believing volume alone drives performance. But without a strong brief and strategic direction, even a high volume of creative will fail. I've seen accounts cranking out 100+ assets a month with a win rate below 5%. That's a volume game, not a strategy.

Meta's algorithm doesn't reward "more of the same." It rewards differentiation.

What actually matters is the quality of your brief and the clarity of your creative strategy. If your brief is weak, it doesn't matter how many assets you produce, you're just making more of the wrong thing.

Instead of chasing asset counts, invest in better briefs and explore net-new creative concepts. Track your creative win rate. If it's below 10%, you're stuck in a JPEG factory. A good win rate (10-20%) means your strategy is actually working.

The brief is more important than hitting a certain target of assets. Focus on concept counts and strategic creative exploration, not volume.

2. Why are our campaigns getting more expensive?

The knee-jerk reaction is to blame rising costs on competition or platform changes. And sure, those play a role. But in reality, fragmented campaign structures and audience overlap are usually the biggest culprits.

Running too many campaigns or ad sets increases frequency and CPMr (cost per 1,000 people reached), driving inefficiency. I'm still auditing accounts spending six figures a month with 20+ campaigns, 200 ad sets, most of them losing money. The account setup is actively fighting itself.

Here's how to fix it.

Consolidate campaigns. Combine fragmented structures into fewer, stronger campaigns. Depending on your budget and product mix, if you need more than 5 campaigns, you're probably fragmenting your budget and starving your campaigns of conversion data. We just got asked if we run accounts with 50+ campaigns. We don't.

Reduce overlap. Implement a 180-day website visitor exclusion to help focus on net-new audiences and minimise redundant targeting. Exclusion lists are more important than targeting, I'll die on this hill.

Audit your frequency. Increasing frequency is a clear signal of audience saturation. If you're spending the same but reaching fewer users, it's time to adjust. Otherwise you'll pay the price as your awareness drops and your funnel starts to rely on finite warm audiences.

Fragmented campaigns drive up costs. Simplify and consolidate to control spend.

3. How do we scale without creative burnout?

When scaling, most teams fall into the trap of launching "safe" variations of existing ads. Colour swaps, font changes, headline shuffles. These micro-iterations rarely move the needle.

Meta doesn't spend behind creative lookalikes. Tiny tweaks don't add diversity. 95% of new creatives fail when they're not big swing iterations or net-new concepts.

The platform rewards net-new concepts that expand reach, not more of what it already has. Instead of digging in the same creative well, prioritise bold, differentiated concepts that resonate with new audiences.

112 boring ads won't get you growth. 12 diverse ads might. Half should feel on-brand. The other half should push boundaries. More formats. More angles. More risk. That's how you find the breakthroughs. If you're an agency and none of your ideas are getting rejected, you're playing it too safe.

Balance speed with exploration. Build a team or partner that can deliver rapid creative production while still dedicating time to exploring new directions. Some of the brands winning right now are launching 90% organic-feeling, creator-led content and 10% polished paid creative per week.

Scale isn't about more of the same. Invest in big swings and new ideas.

4. Should we duplicate winning ads or scale them where they are?

This one comes up constantly. A brand finds a winner and immediately wants to duplicate it into a new campaign or ad set at a bigger budget.

I reviewed an account last week where they had moved a top performing ad from Testing into a larger scaling ad set, and paused it in the Testing campaign. Spend dropped overnight. Ad CVR dropped by 30%.

"Test and Duplicate" sounds great in theory. In practice, you're resetting the ad's learnings and throwing it into a new auction environment where it has to prove itself all over again.

For every drop shipper day trading a million ad sets there's a Chad scaling a single budget. The brands doing $20 mil top line aren't duplicating winners across 8 campaigns with small budgets. They're running a simplified structure, sometimes just an ASC and an ABO, and scaling spend where performance already exists.

Here's what to do instead. If an ad is winning, scale the budget where it is. Don't move it, don't duplicate it, don't touch the thing that's working. If you want more control over new ads, segment your assets, test new angles in a separate ad set without disrupting winners. Apply manual bidding like cost caps or limited budgets to control risk on the new stuff.

Every time I raise my budget, CPA tanks for days, so founders duplicate winning campaigns at small budgets instead. This creates 8 duplicate campaigns with the same ads, same targeting, overlapping audiences, and frequency through the roof. The "fix" becomes the problem.

Duplication is a trap. Scale where the performance is.

5. What metrics actually matter?

The default is obsessing over lagging indicators like ROAS or CPA. And look, these metrics matter. But they're often symptoms, not root causes. The real insights come from leading indicators that show whether your campaigns are set up for sustainable growth.

I've audited accounts where a brand was ready to fire their agency because "all the winning ads have terrible ROAS." Their logic: Ad A had $300 spend, 6 conversions, 4.8x ROAS = "winner." Ad B had $9,000 spend, 180 conversions, 2.4x ROAS = "loser." Low spend, high ROAS does not equal a winning ad.

What to measure to help drive growth.

Net-new visitors. Tools like Triple Whale or Northbeam can help track whether campaigns are driving fresh traffic. Are you reaching more new people than you did last year? If not, you're just recycling the same audience.

Incremental impact. Run Meta conversion lift tests to determine the true incremental cost of conversions. Free will is running these, just set one up today. Account level, not campaign A vs campaign B. Two weeks minimum depending on spend.

Audience saturation. Monitor frequency and CPMr to avoid diminishing returns. If your CPMr is climbing every month and your reach is falling, no budget hack will save you.

Creative win rate. Track formats, angles, and creators. Win rate isn't just a metric, it's a map. It tells you where to double down and where to stop wasting time.

Measure leading indicators like incremental lift, net-new reach, and creative win rate, not just lagging metrics like ROAS.

Final Thoughts

These questions aren't just tactical, they're diagnostic. By asking the right ones, brands can uncover hidden inefficiencies, prioritise high-leverage actions, and unlock sustainable growth.

If your campaigns are stuck or your costs are climbing, start here. Audit your campaign structure, creative strategy, and audience targeting. The answers are usually in the boring details.


Back to all articles