We’ve Forgotten How to Wait
· General

We’ve Forgotten How to Wait
Fifteen years of decline.
Eighteen months of patience.
$4.4 billion in growth.
Most marketing departments are trained to think like quants.
Not by choice, by necessity. The modern marketing org runs on attribution windows and cost-per-acquisition. Every dollar needs to return a dollar… trackable, provable, clean.
There is nothing wrong with that.
However, when the board starts asking questions, the instinct is to do what the system rewards: cut the brand budget, double down on direct response, and call it discipline.
It isn't discipline.
It's a system optimized for the short term.
Here's the reframe: performance marketing doesn't work against brand building. It works because of it.
Give people a story worth believing and your ads get cheaper, your conversion rates climb, and your customers stop shopping around.
The story is the performance. The performance funds the story.
That's Performance Storytelling.
It's the unfair advantage that any brand can build.
Fifteen years of New Balance's decline proved it.
So did the four-point-four-billion-dollar comeback that followed.
What comes next is a story that has been shared and it has been written about, but I wanted to spend my own time with the write up.
Researching, learning as much as I could. Deducing my own takeaways.
Framing it all with the Little Things, Done Right mentality that guides me.
A selfish exercise that hopefully provides a good read for you today.
The Bet Nobody Wanted to Make
Jim Davis bought New Balance in 1972 for $10,000 on the day of the Boston Marathon.
Six employees. Thirty pairs of shoes a day. He and his family still own an estimated 95% of the company today. No IPO, no private equity, no Wall Street analysts watching every quarter.
Jim Davis has said it plainly: as a private company, you can make decisions on a five or ten-year horizon that public companies structurally cannot afford to make.
His son Chris Davis grew up with a different perspective on the brand than any outside hire ever could. He's said that as a kid, he and his sister never viewed New Balance as a company, they viewed it as a sibling.
The favorite child in the family, as he put it, was New Balance.
He joined the company in 2008 and became CMO in 2020. Forbes now ranks him the second most influential CMO in the world.
This matters because when Chris walked into his father's office in April 2020 with a question: do you trust me enough to look crazy for a while?
He wasn't pitching a stranger. He was asking the man who'd built the brand from nothing whether the family was willing to bet on it again.
Consider the alternative. Nike's stock fell nearly 60% from its 2021 peak as its DTC-heavy strategy unraveled. When they missed earnings in June 2024, they lost close to $28 billion in market cap in a single day.
That kind of exposure doesn't just create pressure, it creates institutional panic that makes long-term brand thinking almost impossible to defend in a boardroom.
New Balance doesn't have that vulnerability. And in April 2020, that structural freedom was the difference between a bold strategy getting a yes and getting quietly killed before it ever started.
The pitch was simple and terrifying. Flip the ratio.
Seventy percent brand. Thirty percent activation. In a pandemic.
With fifteen years of the "dad shoe" label calcified around their neck.
The CEO said yes. Most boards would have said no.
But this wasn't most boards and this wasn't most CMOs.
The patience that followed wasn't just personal discipline.
It was built into the architecture of who they were.
For the next eighteen months, it looked like the worst decision in sneaker history.
Revenue kept falling. The collaborations were live. The gifting was moving.
The cultural machinery was turning…
The spreadsheet just hadn't felt it yet.
Give Before You Ask
Think of it as a ratio.
Every brand is either giving or asking at any given moment. Giving is education, entertainment, cultural credibility… anything that makes a customer feel something before you've asked for a dollar. Asking is the ad. The promo. The "buy now."
Most brands ask too much and give too little.
They skip the relationship and go straight to the transaction, earn nothing, and want everything. Then they wonder why loyalty is dead and margins are held hostage by whoever's running the cheapest promotion.
Brands that get the ratio right, roughly 60% giving, 40% asking, outperform the ones chasing short-term activation every single time.
The math works.
Most marketing departments just aren't rewarded for waiting long enough to see it.
New Balance found the people who decide what's cool, not the most famous, the most credible, and gave them shoes. No contracts. No required posts. No metrics attached. Just product, handed to people with taste, and the trust to let it land.
Teddy Santis at Aimé Leon Dore. Salehe Bembury. Joe Freshgoods. The right names. People whose audiences trusted their taste without question.
When they wore New Balance, it didn't feel like marketing. It felt like a discovery.
Santis pulled the 550 from New Balance's archive, a basketball shoe from 1989 the brand had shelved and forgotten. He saw it differently.
When the ALD collab dropped in October 2020, it sold out within hours. A $110 shoe was reselling for $300 to $500 on StockX within weeks.
Thirty years of dust, gone overnight.
Nothing about the shoe changed.
Everything about the story did.
The Athlete Nobody Else Wanted Yet
The same philosophy that found the 550 in the archive extends to the athlete roster.
New Balance doesn't sign the sure thing. They sign the person they believe in before the market confirms it, before the price becomes impossible and every other brand is circling.
In October 2018, New Balance signed Coco Gauff when she was fourteen and ranked 6th in ITF junior girls.
No Grand Slams. No magazine covers. No bidding war.
Gauff later said she didn't even know the contract value until she read about it.
She called it the best decision she ever made.
When she won, the logo was right there. Not as a sponsor who swooped in after the fact, but as a partner who'd been there from the beginning.
Gauff now has her own signature line, the CG1 and CG2, making her the first New Balance tennis player with a personalized sneaker.
Then there's Shohei Ohtani who signed in January 2024, months before he led the Dodgers to a World Series title and cemented himself as the most compelling athlete in baseball.
The most watched player in the sport, lacing up in a brand most people had written off five years earlier.
This isn't coincidence.
It's the same eye that spotted the 550.
Nike and Adidas spend nine figures on names everyone already knows.
New Balance bets on the names everyone's about to know.
One is acquisition. The other is belief.
Pull Before You Push
By the time the 550 hit Foot Locker, it didn't feel like a Foot Locker shoe.
Most brands get this backwards.
They flood retail first, then try to manufacture desire through ads.
Push without pull.
The product sits on shelves competing on price with everything next to it.
That's not brand building. That's slow liquidation.
New Balance built the desire before they needed the shelf.
Retail captured demand that already existed.
The sale happened before the customer walked into the store.
Everything else was logistics.
The Eighteen Months Nobody Talks About
This is the part of the story most marketing systems aren't built to survive.
For eighteen months after Davis flipped the ratio, the numbers kept sliding.
The board gets impatient. Finance starts circling.
Someone says let's just run a promo and the entire long game collapses for a short-term bump that compounds into nothing.
Davis didn't flinch.
He was on the streets. Talking to influencers. Watching culture.
Reading signals the P&L couldn't see yet.
Sales are a lagging indicator. By the time revenue moves, the brand work that caused it is ancient history.
The skill isn't optimizing the harvest. It's learning to trust the planting and holding steady while everyone around you is losing theirs.
Then, in the back half of 2021, something gave.
The brand posted the strongest year in its history.
Revenue didn't spike and fade, it compounded.
Twenty percent up, year after year.
A business worth three-and-a-half billion dollars in 2020 had nearly doubled by 2024.
They're not done.
Meanwhile, At Nike…
While Davis was quietly building, Nike was doing the exact opposite.
Under CEO John Donahoe, Nike went heavy on performance marketing, pulled back from wholesale partners like Foot Locker and JD Sports, and gutted the culturally resonant storytelling that had made them untouchable for two decades.
Own the customer relationship. Cut out the middleman.
Let the data drive everything. Clean on a whiteboard.
Sales dropped 10%. Net income fell 44%.
That June 2024 earnings call erased $28 billion in market cap before close of business.
Elliott Hill, a 32-year Nike lifer pulled out of retirement, took over in October 2024 with one admission that said everything: "We lost our obsession with sport."
What followed was a brand in full reversal.
Nike returned to the Super Bowl in 2025 for the first time in 27 years with Wieden+Kennedy's"So Win" campaign with nine female athletes…
Pure emotional storytelling.
(Video)
Then cameACG.
All Conditions Gear was born 1989, abandoned, recommitted to, abandoned again, relaunched as a standalone outdoor brand (see the trend?)
The campaign film was executive produced by Jeff Tremaine, co-founder of Jackass.
Shot on grainy colour-saturated film. Narrated in a David Attenborough wildlife-documentary voice.
It ends with a single dry line: "Welcome to the world of ACG. Apologies."
That word is doing a lot of work. It's a brand giving itself permission to be strange again to make something that couldn't survive a committee optimizing for click-through rates.
(I’ll break down ACG in our next post)
(Video)
The All Conditions Express took it further still.
Nike converted an Italian commuter train into a fully branded ACG experience at the Milan Winter Olympics, transporting athletes and creators from the city into the Alps.
No swoosh. Just the triangular ACG logo, burnt orange everywhere, and a brand behaving like it had something to prove.
It does. And for the first time in years, it's proving it in the right direction.
Two iconic brands. Opposite experiments. Opposite outcomes.
Data without story is noise. Story without data is art.
The brands that marry the two are the ones that compound.
New Balance figured this out first.
Nike is paying tuition to learn it now (that feels weird to even write).
But at least they're back in class.
Little Things, Done Right
The 550 was in New Balance's basement for thirty years.
Worth nothing until it was worth everything.
The archive strategy didn't stop there.
The 990, the 991, the 993… each pulled back into culture under the same philosophy.
Trust the right people with the right product.
Tell the right story.
Step back and let it breathe.
New Balance's heritage became their competitive advantage precisely because they stopped being embarrassed by it.
Most brands are sitting on the same gold and don't know it.
The instinct is always to build something new, spend on the next thing. But sometimes the most powerful move is to look inward before you look outward.
The turnaround wasn't one brilliant campaign. It was a thousand little things, done right.
Trusting the cultural signal over the quarterly report, for eighteen months, when every number said otherwise.
The gifted shoe with no strings. The collaborations with no script.
The CMO who read the streets before the spreadsheet caught up.
These aren't expensive moves. They're disciplined ones.
And discipline, compounded quietly over time, is what turned a dad shoe into one of the most compelling brand stories of the last decade.
You are probably sleeping on some archives as well.
The Takeaway:
Stop asking before you've given.
Stop pushing before you've pulled.
Stop harvesting before you've planted.
The archive is probably full. The people are out there.
The story already exists.
Most brands just don't have the patience to find it.
Fifteen years of decline.
Eighteen months of patience.
$4.4 billion in growth.
The shoe didn't change.
The story did.
Until next time — Jake