When Was The Last Time You Made a Winning Ad?

· Articles

When Was The Last Time You Made a Winning Ad?

Phil here, Director of Paid Social. When was the last time you made a winning ad?

Think about it. Not a hook that did okay for a week. Not an ad that spent $500 before fizzling. A winner. Something that scaled, hit your target CPA, held for more than a fortnight, and made you feel like the account was moving.

If the answer is a few months ago, read on.

You've probably wondered if you're getting worse

At some point most creative teams have this conversation internally. The wins have slowed down. The hooks that used to work don't land the same way. You're launching more, testing faster, iterating harder - and finding less.

And in the back of your mind there's a question you don't really want to ask out loud: are we just worse at making ads now?

Here's the thing. Your skills are better than they were two years ago. You've made hundreds of ads. You know your customer better. You understand hooks, you've tested angles, you've figured out what your product story actually is. Everything should be compounding.

So why are you finding fewer winners?

You're probably not worse at making ads. Your account stopped giving your ads a fair test.

What a fair test actually looks like

When a new ad goes into your prospecting campaign, it should be shown to people who have never seen your brand before. That's what prospecting means. The metric that tells you whether that's happening is new visitor percentage - the share of people coming to your site from that ad who have never visited before.

For a new prospecting ad in a healthy account, new visitor percentage should be around 75–80%. If it's 40%, the ad is being served to warm audiences. People who already know you. Who might already be on your email list. Who've seen ten of your previous ads and didn't buy.

Those audiences convert at an acceptable rate, just often enough to make the ad look like it's working. Then the performance drops. You log it as a failed creative and brief another one.

The creative didn't fail. It was served to the wrong people and never got a chance to prove itself cold.

Why this happens

The most common cause is campaign overlap. When you run multiple campaigns targeting similar audiences with no strong exclusions, Meta doesn't need to look for new people. It already knows who's likely to convert in your account. It goes back to them.

I audited an account this week. Eleven active campaigns. 52% overlap between them - meaning more than half the total reach across all campaigns was the same people being reached again. Spend was up 142% year to date. Reach was up 35%.

They'd been increasing creative volume to try to find winners. More briefs, faster production, higher output. The ads were getting better. The overlap was getting worse.

CPMr was up 41% year to date. Frequency up 39%. Every new ad launched into that account had a smaller and smaller slice of genuinely cold audience to work with. The account was eating its own reach.

Phil Kiel
@PhilKiel · Feb 11 2026

Spending more. Reaching fewer people. Welcome to the 'death spiral.' It’s a slow bleed that kills growth if you don’t catch it early.

Why it happens:

– Launching too many ad sets relative to your budget increases Frequency

– Lack of creative, format, message diversity

– Relaxed exclusions

– Scaling past your TAM

What happens next:

– Net new reach shrinks.

– Spend rises to compensate.

– CPMR (cost per reach) skyrockets.

– You blame, CVR, ROAS, the algorithm

Fewer new customers, higher costs.

Fix it early:

1. Watch net new % (new audience vs returning).

2. Exclude past visitors/social engagers to force colder reach.

3. Consolidate campaigns to simplify testing.

4. Spend on non-PUR campaigns (easy to get wrong)

Shrinking reach isn’t a dip. It’s a warning.

↗ View on X

More creative made it worse

When you increase volume into an account with overlap, you’re not running more tests. You’re running the same test more times against the same warm pool.

The faster you produce creative, the faster you exhaust that pool. Then you produce more to fix the performance problem, which exhausts it further. From the outside it looks like a creative quality problem. The people closest to it start questioning their own judgment.

It's a structure problem.

Phil Kiel
@PhilKiel · Feb 24 2026

If you're launching 20 ads a week and most of them look similar, you'd be better off launching 10 with a bigger gap between each one.

Small iterations don't move the needle anymore. Andromeda doesn't spend behind creative lookalikes.

Test more different stuff. Only start iterating once you've found something that works. Then iterate hard.

↗ View on X

What to fix before you brief another ad

Consolidate first. Fewer live campaigns. Fewer ad sets with overlapping audiences. Give the budget somewhere to go without bidding against itself in the same auction.

Add proper exclusions. Website visitors, social engagers, email list — out of prospecting. The algorithm should have no warm audience to default to. If it can't find cold people, it'll look harder.

Then relaunch creative and watch the new visitor percentage on day one. If it hits 75–80%, the account is working and your ads are getting a real test. If it stays at 40%, there's more structural work to do before creative quality makes any difference.

The question isn't whether you've got worse at making ads. The question is whether your ads have ever been tested against the audience they were built for.

Read more about CPMr:https://taikundigital.com/phil-kiel/cpmr-calculation

Book a call with me.


Back to all articles